top of page

PSA Photo Critiques

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Fritz Fryer

Harlequin Water Glass

Intermediate

4.5

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Creative image. Monotone works well. Glass is sharp and there are no blown out areas. Reflection adds to the image. Removing the little strip of black on left side would improve the image.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Devin Abbe

Arkansas Knifemaker Forging Steel

Intermediate

4.5

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Good story. The red hot iron adds interest. Subject is sharp with blurred background. Head of hammer is a bit blurry showing movement. Nice.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Larry Gilley

I’ll BEE Very Busy

Intermediate

4

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Bee and flower are very sharp. The eye of the bee is looking at the maker which is good. Background is muted but perhaps could be muted a little more allowing for more focus on the main subject. The image appeared very small.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Charles Scott

Bald Cypress in Infrared

Intermediate

4

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Roots are sharp and the main focus. Infrared works well. Perhaps crop a little on the left side as light area and dark one below it are a bit distracting as eye goes there.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Bob Ward

The First Bow

Intermediate

4

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Tells a good story. There are bright spots, especially at the top that could be toned down or cropped out from the top.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Kelly Hernandez

Hunt Stonen Sculptures

Intermediate

3.5

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Nice use of shutter speed to make the water look milky. There are two areas that appear “foggy”. In the trees on the left side and area above the big ball.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Shannon Kingsbury

We All Fall Down

Intermediate

3.5

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Good use of black and white for this image as it adds to the story of being old and falling down. Some of the dark shadows could be lightened a little to see more texture in the shadows.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Wes Jones

Where Silence Lingers

Intermediate

5

1st Place

2026

/

November

Critique:

Good ICM image. Movement works well and yet lets viewer see what the subject is. Textures and tones makes this a good image.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Bruce Bean

Thorncrown Chapel

Intermediate

3.5

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Very clear image. Orange lights on left add interest.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Alan Roberts

Playing with Fire

Advanced

3.5

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Warm colors balance with the black background. Shows movement. The whites in the fire attract attention and appear blown out. They could be toned down.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Cliff McKenzie

Pogo Stick on Steroids

Advanced

5

1st Place

2026

/

November

Critique:

Great action photo. Expression on his face adds to the story. Audience also add to the story and grounds the image and gives sense of space. Well done!

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

David Thomas

All Quiet at the Fair

Advanced

4

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Colorful photo. Title matches the image. Zooming out would have included the ride on the right as it is now cut off at top and side.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Alex Woodcock

Jump!

Advanced

4.5

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Good action shot. Top of building at bottom grounds image and gives sense of how high he has jumped.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Amy Dumas

Night to Day in Glacier Bay

Advanced

4.5

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Nice panoramic image. Almost monotone blue image except for the bit of color in the sky which adds to the image.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Larry Golden

Searching for the Milky Way

Advanced

3.5

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Title matches story. Light takes viewer through to the bright area of the sky. If maker had shifted camera to left a little, it would have put person and light more on the 1/3 line and cut off some of the dark area on the right.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Dolph Miller

HE DID WHAT!

Advanced

3.5

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Image is sharp throughout. Yellow and blue are complimentary colors. Angled lines take viewer through image. Not clear how title relates to image.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Lily Green

Share and Share Alike

Advanced

3.5

​

2026

/

November

Critique:

Good composition. Curve of flowers take viewer through the image. Muted background is nice. The subject appears to be over sharpened. A bit of petal on left side could be taken out.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Larry Golden

St. Bontiface

Advanced

5

​

2026

/

September

Critique:

Flipping this image will give you a very different feel that this orientation. I can't tell you which one you will like the best, as I actually quite like both to them. Each story is just a little different. You did a very nice job of blending the monochrome with the color. Good job.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Alex Woodcock

Splish Splash

Advanced

4

​

2026

/

September

Critique:

This is a sweet, fun image. However, the composition would be helped enormously if you flip the image. Yes, you then have to blur out the numbers, but a few minutes on that, and you have a much stronger result.

Photographer:

Title:

Level:

Score:

Award:

Year/Month:

Alan Roberts

Under Construction

Advanced

4

​

2026

/

September

Critique:

I like the story here, and the technicals are good. My one real problem is that I want to see more of his face and hands. Although strong, the composition would be even stronger with a few degrees of shift.

bottom of page